PreviousNext

Circumcision ban in Germany 'worst attack on Jews since Holocaust'

By // News | Circumcision ban in Germany 'worst attack on Jews since Holocaust'
Email to a friend Plain text Print version // Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font
  • Circumcision has been practised for 4,000 years by the Jewish community and cannot be changed, says rabbi

By Daily Mail Reporter

PUBLISHED: 04:13 EST, 13 July 2012 | UPDATED: 04:13 EST, 13 July 2012

A German court's ban on circumcising baby boys has provoked a rare show of unity between Jews, Muslims and Christians who see it as a threat to religious freedom.

Doctors have also warned it could increase health risks by forcing the practice underground.

President of the Conference of European Rabbis, Pinchas Goldschmidt, has furiously condemned the decision by a German court to ban circumcision

President of the Conference of European Rabbis, Pinchas Goldschmidt (right), has furiously condemned the decision by a German court to ban circumcision

European rabbis meeting in Berlin yesterday promised to defy the ruling by a court in the city of Cologne last month. They plan further talks with Muslim and Christian leaders in Stuttgart next week to see how they can fight the ban together.

'We urge the Jewish community in Germany and circumcisers to continue to perform circumcisions and not to wait for a change in the law,' said the chief rabbi of Moscow Pinchas Goldschmidt.

Goldschmidt said outlawing circumcision was the 'worst attack on Jews since the Holocaust.' He demanded that Angela Merkel's government intervened to guarantee their religious rights.

He added that the the ban is a new example of creeping prejudice in European law against non-Christians, after a Swiss ban on minarets, French and Belgian bans on Islamic veils in public, and an attempted Dutch ban on halal meat.

The Cologne court took action after police were alerted by a doctor who treated a Muslim boy for bleeding after he underwent circumcision. It emphasised it did not ban circumcision, but wanted families to wait until their sons were older. So far the ban applies only to the area of the Cologne court's jurisdiction.

In a country that is sensitive to charges of intolerance and discrimination, especially against Jews because of the Holocaust perpetrated by the Nazis during World War Two, many politicians including the foreign minister have criticised the ruling.

Germany is home to about 120,000 Jews and 4 million Muslims. Many of the latter are originally from Turkey, which also condemned last month's court ruling.

The rabbis have lobbied members of the German and European parliaments to push for legislation that would stop the ban from being copied by other parts of Germany and Europe. This could be done via a law to exempt religious minorities, similar to that which permits the religious preparation of kosher and halal meat.

Jewish and Muslim religious leaders met European Parliament officials in Brussels this week to complain about what they called 'an affront to our basic religious and human rights'.

The father of a baby boy reads a prayer before giving the Mohel the blade for a circumcision

The father of a baby boy reads a prayer before giving the Mohel the blade for a circumcision

Germany's opposition Greens promised to help seek legislation that would entrench religious freedoms for Jews and Muslims.

'After the summer break we want to discuss with experts and relevant groups whether there is a way to tackle this problem in a legal way and to guarantee the legal rights of Jews and Muslims,' said senior Green lawmaker Renate Kuenast.

Jews usually circumcise male infants eight days after birth, while the time for Muslim circumcision varies according to family, religion and country.

'Circumcision represents the basis for belonging to the Jewish community. It has been practised for 4,000 years and cannot be changed,' Goldschmidt said.

The 40 rabbis attending the Berlin conference decided to gather Jewish circumcisers in Germany into one association to further guarantee safety standards in the operation.

'Jewish families having babies now don't know how to behave because they are afraid. Circumcisers continuously call us to ask whether they can perform circumcisions or not. Things cannot continue like this,' said German rabbi Avichai Apel.

The head of the German Medical Association, Frank Ulrich Montgomery, said the ban meant there was 'an increased risk of this task being performed by lay people which, because of poor hygiene conditions, could lead to serious complications'.

But Montgomery said he sadly had to advise his colleagues to refrain from performing the operation until the legal situation had been clarified, 'otherwise they could face prosecution'.

The World Health Organisation cites research showing that male circumcision can reduce the risk of AIDS, and 44 members of parliament in Zimbabwe underwent circumcision in June to promote awareness of HIV/AIDS.

Germany's ambassador to Israel has assured lawmakers there that Berlin will try to resolve the problem quickly, while the justice minister has advised the Jewish and Muslim communities to seek redress via Germany's Constitutional Court.

'I see that within a democracy there are different bodies taking part in the lawmaking process but from our point of view, the deadline is not tomorrow but yesterday,' responded Rabbi Goldschmidt.

He warned that many of Germany's Jewish community, which has grown from just 3,000 in 1945 following the Holocaust, could end up emigrating if Germany cannot ensure full religious freedom.

Tagged : No tags for this article

Headlines Newsview all

Inside the Tory Black and White Ball: Booze, tycoons and bizarre auctions at the top secret fundraiser

David Cameron went cap-in-hand to super-rich Tory donors last night, at a top-secret and lavish fundraising ball. Super-rich Tory donors paid up to £15,000 a table ... Full story

No10 insists thousands of refugees could reach UK "overnight" after Brexit despite claim being ridiculed

Thousands of asylum seekers could flock to Britain “overnight” if the UK quits Europe, David Cameron 's spokesman claimed today despite ridicule from anti-EU campaigners. Leaving ... Full story

Lord Bramall's son calls for an inquiry into what evidence police had before they raided his father's home and launched a 10-month sex abuse investigation against him

A police probe into the former armed forces chief was dropped last month It was abandoned amid controversy surrounding Operation Midland The 92-year-old D-Day veteran's home was ... Full story

France insists it WON'T scrap the border deal with Britain as the PM is left reeling by claims he's scaremongering after warning the Calais Jungle camp could come to Kent

French sources make clear the border treaty with Britain is not on the table Nigel Farage today claims the row shows David Cameron is 'desperate' Bitter row ... Full story

UK weather: Storm Imogen brings 100mph hurricane-force winds leaving thousands of Brits without any power

More than 15,000 residents in Britain have been left without power as Storm Imogen batters Britain with hurricane-force winds reaching speeds of almost 100mph. Coastal communities ... Full story

Salford halls of residence murder probe after man found dead

Police have launched a murder probe after a man was found dead at a student halls of residence in Greater Manchester. The body of the 30-year-old ... Full story

Police probe mystery of body found a MILE from crashed car

Police are probing a mysterious crash after a body was found more than a mile from where a car careered off the road. Officers searching for ... Full story

'I've forgiven myself': Rielle Hunter says she is finally over disgraced presidential hopeful John Edwards, reveals he is a great dad but did not mean to hurt his terminally ill wife 

Hunter and Edwards began their affair in 2006 and became public in 2007 She fell pregnant that year but Edwards didn't admit paternity until 2010 Nine years ...

Bernie Sanders supporters back on Tinder after being banned for campaigning

Robyn Gedrich, 23, from New Jersey, and Haley Lent, 22, from Iowa, were locked out of Tinder for spamming other users Both were using the app ...

Eli Manning explains looking gutted at the Broncos Super Bowl touchdown

Eli Manning, 35, was analyzing the game and staying focused Peyton previously said his brother wouldn't relax until the end Was watching with the rest of the ...

Daughter meets father for the first time after tracking him down but is then raped by him

A daughter who met her dad for the first time after tracking him down was then raped by him, a court heard. The woman, from Melbourne, ... Full story

Comment on: Circumcision ban in Germany 'worst attack on Jews since Holocaust'

Rate this article

0

Breaking News

Proposed new snooping laws meant to make clear when the police and security services can access your data have been rushed and are full of holes, MPs blast 

Intelligence and Security Committee blasts Theresa May's draft legislation MPs say the Bill fails to bring together all powers of intelligence agencies And they insist the proposed ...

Father-of-three ex-soldier who travelled to Kurdistan to fight against Isis tells of 'five months of hell' after he was arrested as a suspected terrorist 

Adrian Harrison, 31, was arrested the moment he stepped off the plane He had spent three months volunteering with the Peshmerga in Kurdistan Harrison was locked up, ...

'She always talked of running away with him': Friend of murdered Virginia girl says 13-year-old wanted to get married and start a family with Virignia Tech freshman, 18, accused of stabbing her to death

Natasha Bryant told the Washington Post that she tried to warn her friend Nicole Lovell, 13, against speaking to suspect David Eisenhauer, 18  Lovell was found ...

George Osborne's psychiatrist brother Adam begged his mistress not to report him

George Osborne's psychiatrist brother, Adam, begged his lover's silence  Dr Osborne, who was married, had a two-year affair with his patient He had been treating her for ...

Helen Hall receives 'threatening email' from two-star Michelin restaurant Sat Bains

Helen Hall, 46, booked table for two at Restaurant Sat Bains, Nottingham She cancelled on same day after daughter Eleanor, six, had chest infection Mrs Hall posted ...

Elaine Gordon who got £26,000 benefits despite working as a barmaid pulling pints

Elaine Gordon, 59, of Birmingham claimed she could barely hold a glass But investigators filmed her pulling beers from heavy cask ale pumps Seen lifting items despite ...

Jeremy Corbyn to deny Labour's Jack Straw a chance to join the House of Lords

Straw had been lined up to continue his political career in the Upper HouseHe was caught in a lobbying sting but later cleared by Commons ...

Pro-choice group hits out at Doritos Super Bowl 50 'humanizing fetuses'

Abortion-rights organization NARAL tweeted during Super Bowl that Doritos' 'Ultrasound' ad employs 'anti-choice' tactics Also accused snack giant of reinforcing 'sexist' tropes by presenting dads as clueless and moms as ...

US Olympic committee forced to deny telling athletes to avoid Rio 2016 Games over fears of catching the Zika virus

It was claimed that officials told a conference call athletes should consider missing Rio 2016 Olympic Games as Brazil is the epicenter of Zika crisisBut ...

Felling the Bern: Emily Ratajkowski heats things up in New Hampshire campaigning for Sanders in a crop top despite below-freezing temperatures and a snow storm

Emily Ratajkowski introduced Bernie Sanders during an appearance at the University of New Hampshire on Monday nightDespite temperatures that were well below freezing and a ...